Alberta control on auto insurance premiums hurting drivers: report

Article content material

The province’s management on auto insurance coverage premiums could also be doing extra hurt than good, a latest public coverage report has discovered.

The report by Calgary economist Jack Mintz for the Insurance coverage Bureau of Canada states that Alberta’s worth controls on auto insurance coverage — akin to the speed cap and Alberta’s Grid system — drive insurance coverage corporations out of the market, ergo making it tougher for drivers to search out aggressive protection.

Article content material

“This example makes the coverage intent of worth caps finally self-defeating,” Mintz wrote within the report, printed Oct. 11. “It’s advanced to manage and distorts costs.”

Mintz really helpful the value caps and grid score system be “abolished” in favour of a market-controlled system, the place corporations compete for patrons with “competitively decided contracts.”

The federal government, he added, may set minimal situations akin to experience-rating, primary insurance coverage advantages and deductibles and co-payments to make sure extra reasonably priced premium ranges for drivers.

If the objective is to scale back auto premiums, the province ought to think about both abolishing or lowering the insurance coverage tax premium from 4 to three per cent, he acknowledged.

The grid system, worth caps ineffective

The grid score system was first carried out in 2004 as a means to make sure new drivers may get an reasonably priced premium, by capping the premiums that insurance coverage corporations may cost for primary protection in addition to stopping substantial annual will increase.

Article content material

Article content material

Over the previous 20 years, the variety of drivers within the province has grown, outstepping the speed of recent drivers, rendering the system ineffective, in accordance with consultants. 

A 2022 report by Deloitte LLP discovered the variety of drivers grew by 29.6 per cent up to now 5 years. It additionally discovered high-risk drivers, with histories of infractions and/or at-fault claims had been receiving subsidies of $2,516 or extra.

In January 2023, Alberta carried out a one-year freeze on auto insurance coverage charges to sort out affordability considerations, to which some auto insurers responded by exiting the market.

The freeze was adopted by a “good driver” charge cap of three.7 per cent in November 2023, to maintain charges low for drivers with a protected driving historical past of not less than 4 years.

“Value caps distort pricing and results in monetary instability when insurance coverage corporations can’t earn ample earnings to take care of capital funding,” Mintz highlighted within the 2024 report.

“Their unfavourable impression on the provision of protection — as a consequence of both insurer withdrawal or gross sales restrictions — forces many drivers to search out new, typically costlier protection, elsewhere available in the market,” the report added.

Article content material

Insurer prices rising, corporations leaving the market

Between 2013 and 2023, the report discovered declare prices and insurance coverage premium prices rose at a sooner charge than insurance coverage premiums. Actual insurance coverage premium prices, for instance, rose by 18 per cent, however the common improve in insurance coverage premiums has been 4.1 per cent.

Declare prices and bodily harm declare prices have additionally risen over the identical time frame by a median of 6.3 per cent and eight per cent, respectively. “These prices clearly put strain onto the premium prices,” the report acknowledged.

Further cumulative bills associated to administration, info know-how, advertising and marketing, renewal prices and a 4 per cent insurance coverage premium tax, all of which may suggest an extra value of $450 to supply insurance coverage in 2023, the report added.

Return on fairness between 2012 and 2022 has been unfavourable 1.2 per cent in addition to 0.5 per cent over the previous six years, excepting 2021 and 2022, the report acknowledged.

The return to fairness in 2021 and 2022 averaged at 12.3 per cent and 6.8 per cent respectively.

Since 2013, 10 auto insurance coverage suppliers have introduced they’re leaving the Alberta market. Three corporations introduced in 2024 that they would depart as a consequence of charge caps and poor profitability.

Article content material

In July 2023, Alberta’s finance minister confirmed to Postmedia that an organization representing as many as 16,000 drivers supplied the superintendent of insurance coverage with discover it could be withdrawing from the province by November the identical yr.

Reverting to a aggressive market

Mintz steered reverting to a aggressive market that encourages worth competitors, client alternative and innovation.

“Insurance coverage that reduces the dangers related to driving additionally helps demand for cars and elevated driving within the financial system,” he wrote within the report.

Authorities reform insurance policies ought to prioritize financial effectivity, equity and monetary stability, two of which worth caps don’t do, the report explains. “The Grid utilized by Alberta consists of varied worth caps to guard sure drivers from increased insurance coverage premiums, however this comes on the expense of different drivers who must bear increased premiums such pretty much as good drivers,” it acknowledged. “The Grid is advanced to handle and must be abolished.”

The report steered contemplating a hybrid system of no-fault insurance coverage and tort insurance coverage, which permits drivers the suitable to sue for extra vital claims akin to demise, impairment and misplaced earnings.

Article content material