It’s been some time because the XUV, Harrier and Compass shared a body, and so much has modified since. We convey them collectively once more to see how they stack up.
Again in 2019, we in contrast the Tata Harrier, Mahindra XUV500 and the Jeep Compass, and the Harrier emerged victorious for being true to Tata’s ‘extra automobile per automobile’ philosophy with a stellar worth for cash proposition. Half a decade later, the sport has modified. On one hand, the Jeep Compass and Tata Harrier have undergone vital midlife transformations, whereas on the opposite, the new-age XUV700 has changed the XUV500. So a rematch was inevitable.
For this comparability, we’ve taken their front-wheel-driven diesel-automatic variants into consideration. The costliest right here is the Jeep Compass Black Shark, priced at Rs 28.69 lakh (ex-showroom). By the way, the Compass diesel-auto 4×2 will get an excellent pricier ‘Mannequin S’ variant at Rs 30.19 lakh. The Tata Harrier in its Fearless+ Darkish variant is priced at Rs 26.44 lakh. Because the five-seater XUV700 is simply out there as much as its mid-spec AX5 (Rs 20.09 lakh), for this comparability, we’ve taken the absolutely loaded 4×2 seven-seater AX7L variant that’s priced at Rs 25.79 lakh.
Tata Harrier vs Mahindra XUV700 vs Jeep Compass: exterior and design
On account of its smaller dimensions, the Jeep Compass seems dwarfed by its burly rivals. However the suave Jeep with its subtle manner and neatly chiselled strains has aged moderately gracefully. It retains typical SUV traits like its flat bonnet and squared-out wheel arches, nevertheless, its body-coloured cladding seems to be extra urbane than rugged, and its two-tone roof visually shortens its peak.
Compass will get a high-quality inside with soft-touch bits; fantastically blends trendy options with conventional design.
The Harrier’s arresting design and imposing highway presence exert critical enchantment. This ‘Darkish’ model with blacked-out components properly enhances its linked LED lights within the entrance, huge 19-inch wheels, and its linked LED tail-lamps, making the Harrier a stunner. Its eye-catching, head-turning design is what makes consumers gravitate in direction of this Tata.
Tata’s well dressed inside isn’t the very best by way of ergonomics or match and end.
The XUV700 sports activities some exaggerated design components like its outsized comma-like DRLs, and in contrast to Mahindras of yore, the XUV700’s styling isn’t fairly as overdone. In actual fact, it seems to be moderately polished and on this take a look at, the well-proportioned XUV additionally has dimension in its favour, being the longest, tallest, and the one with the longest wheelbase.
Tata Harrier vs Mahindra XUV700 vs Jeep Compass: inside and luxury
The Jeep feels most car-like on this firm, with comparatively low seating, nevertheless, its seats are the comfiest of the lot, and its driving place, the sportiest. Its inside design is a lovely mix of basic and trendy components. There are many buttons, knobs in addition to analogue dials, after which there’s a pleasant, giant touchscreen too. What’s extra, there’s a beneficiant use of soft-touch plastics together with different prime quality bits. On this Black Shark iteration, it additionally will get matte crimson inserts, which do a very good job of breaking the cabin’s all-black monotony.
XUV’s cabin is vivid and ethereal; single pane twin-screen structure provides the cabin an upmarket look.
There’s so much happening within the Harrier’s cabin by way of design, and including modernity are a number of massive screens and contact panels. Its touchscreen is the most important in dimension, and essentially the most feature-packed too, nevertheless, it isn’t devoid of glitches, which cropped up often. The instrument cluster is a ten.2-inch unit just like the XUV, nevertheless, the tiny fonts hamper readability. And whereas the touch-operable local weather management seems to be upmarket, it isn’t straightforward to vary the fan pace on the transfer with out taking your eyes off the highway. Some consumers may discover the all-black inside with gloss-black panels a tad too ‘darkish’, nevertheless, Tata additionally affords splashes of color with different variants of the Harrier to liven its look. Ambient lighting and an illuminated brand additional jazz up its inside to an extent. Like different Tatas, the Harrier’s ergonomics aren’t its energy. The massive central console protrudes into the driving force’s (left) knee room; utilizing the wi-fi charging or USB chargers is difficult; and although the entrance seats have a air flow perform and are electrically operable, these aren’t the comfiest as a consequence of a brief seat squab, which ends up in restricted thigh assist.
Jeep’s slender, darkish cabin diminishes sense of house.
Entering into the XUV after the opposite two looks like an enormous step-up by way of airiness and sense of house, because of its gentle colors. What’s good is that the dashboard design is minimalistic, and the dual display – one every for the instrument cluster and the infotainment, considerably enhances its premium-ness. Even cabin ergonomics are way more agreeable with a number of storage areas, a commanding driving place and good visibility all-round. The entrance seats are among the many comfiest, and whereas our take a look at automobile was an older model, Mahindra now additionally affords entrance seat air flow.
Tata Harrier vs Mahindra XUV700 vs Jeep Compass: rear seat consolation
The Jeep’s rear seat is snug for 2 adults, with ample knee room and the very best thigh assist of the three. Its backrest angle is upright, and headroom for six-footers can be tight. A 3rd occupant received’t really feel welcome both as a consequence of its slender width, and the darkish colors severely hamper the sense of house on supply. What’s good is that although its boot is the smallest on paper, it’s well-shaped and may haul practically as a lot baggage as its bigger rivals.
Tata has essentially the most snug again seat of the lot.
On this contest, it’s the Tata Harrier with the very best backseat expertise. It is extremely spacious and supportive, and the headrest considerably ups consolation ranges. What’s extra is that along with pillar-mounted rear air vents, ample storage and charging provisions additionally add to its practicality. Boot house is beneficiant and an electrically operable tailgate with a hands-free operation provides comfort to the bundle.
XUV700 has a broad and spacious seat; backrest reclines too.
The Mahindra scores effectively on house and luxury too, and it’s the just one which has a reclinable backrest. There’s additionally a boss-mode characteristic, whereby the rear passenger can tug a lever and push the entrance passenger seat all the way in which ahead to unlock extra legroom. And with an virtually flat ground and a beneficiant cabin width, a center passenger can sit right here with cheap wiggle room. With three rows up, boot house is tight, nevertheless, the final row folds flat to disclose beneficiant cargo capability.
Tata Harrier vs Mahindra XUV700 vs Jeep Compass: options
The Tata Harrier is the best-equipped SUV right here boasting of package like 19-inch alloys, the most important 12.3-inch touchscreen, ambient lighting, an illuminated steering wheel and rear window sunshades being unique options. The Harrier and Compass Black Shark, each get an electrically operable tailgate and an electrically operable passenger seat. The XUV700 and Harrier get a full ADAS suite, 360-degree digital camera, ventilated entrance seats and premium audio system (the Tata will get JBL, whereas the XUV700 will get Sony). All three get package like Auto LED headlamps, panoramic sunroofs, electrical driver’s seat with reminiscence, touchscreens with wi-fi Android Auto and Apple CarPlay, dual-zone local weather management, rear air-con vents and wi-fi charging, amongst others.
Tata Harrier vs Mahindra XUV700 vs Jeep Compass: powertrain and perfromance
The Jeep Compass and Tata Harrier are powered by the identical FCA-sourced 2.0-litre diesel engine, which makes an similar 170hp and 350Nm in each vehicles. Nonetheless, the similarities finish there.
Compass is the nicest to drive and is faster than the Harrier, though they’re powered by the identical engine.
On the Compass, transmission duties are carried out by a 9-speed computerized, and although the diesel packs in enough low-end grunt and pulls strongly, there’s no getting away from the transmission’s lazy character. The shifts are gradual, and there are not any paddle shifters for guide management over the transmission both. Nonetheless, outright efficiency isn’t dangerous, and the Compass is definitely faster than the Harrier. What’s additionally an enormous distinction between the 2 vehicles is cabin insulation. The Jeep is much better insulated than the Harrier, thus engine and ambient sounds are comparatively extra muted.
Harrier’s low-speed experience is jittery; handles dangerous roads with aplomb.
On the Tata Harrier, the engine is paired to a 6-speed computerized, which feels a tad higher tuned than the previous. Higher spaced gearing in addition to a extra progressive energy supply make the Harrier really feel moderately easy to drive, however whereas the powertrain feels responsive, rolling acceleration along with your foot pinned to the ground isn’t fairly as spectacular because the Jeep. A standard statement between the Jeep and Harrier is that the enhance from the turbo feels mellowed down put up the BS6.2 replace, therefore energy supply doesn’t really feel as spikey because it was once. The Tata is the one one right here to supply paddle shifters, nevertheless, these are very conservative, and don’t assist an aggressive driving fashion, so this transmission is greatest left in full-automatic mode.
XUV700’s 2.2 diesel is extra refined and faster than the two.0 diesel powering the opposite two.
Mahindra XUV700’s diesel impresses on many fronts and albeit, this powertrain belongs in a unique league altogether. Not solely is it quieter than the Jeep and Tata – with the diesel drone way more muted as compared – it additionally produces class-best 185hp and 450Nm of torque. Having a 100Nm torque benefit over its rivals makes the XUV really feel easy. Energy supply feels freer, a lot smoother and acceleration is deceptively brisk too. Complemented by an intuitive 6-speed computerized, the Mahindra is the quickest right here.
Tata Harrier vs Mahindra XUV700 vs Jeep Compass: experience and suspension
The Jeep Compass’ tight physique management and excellent driving manners will appease driving fans, and regardless of being the sportiest to drive, what’s additionally good is the experience high quality that exudes a way of toughness and indestructibility, and tackles dangerous roads like a champ.
The Jeep’s experience and dealing with feels greatest balanced.
The Harrier using on 19-inch wheels has the busiest low-speed experience of the trio however feels flat and composed as you choose up the tempo. Extremely although, true to its Land Rover-derived underpinnings, it feels adept over tough patches and it smothers imperfections in its path moderately capably. The Harrier isn’t a sporty handler and you’ll really feel its weight round a collection of bends, and it doesn’t instil the identical stage of confidence whereas hustling it on a winding part of highway as the opposite two.
The XUV700 has the nicest low-speed experience on account of softer suspension setup.
Mahindra’s tender suspension setup lends the XUV the comfiest low-speed experience high quality, and its chassis feels rugged whereas traversing off-road trails. Equally spectacular is the XUV’s composure at cruising speeds in addition to its car-like driving manners, which masks its bulk a lot better than the Tata, particularly when driving with verve.
Tata Harrier vs Mahindra XUV700 vs Jeep Compass: verdict
The Jeep Compass’ tough-as-nails DNA, stable fundamentals and fun-to-drive nature bundled in a classy bundle add to its desirability. Nonetheless, it’s the smallest and costliest on this comparability. And with the least variety of options, it additionally scores poorly by way of worth for cash.
That’s the place the Tata Harrier does effectively being the best-equipped of the bunch. Its design is probably its largest promoting level and its highway presence, particularly in its ‘Darkish’ avatar, is just unmatched. What lets it down, nevertheless, is its under par engine refinement, its inside imperfections in addition to uneven low pace experience.
Despite the fact that Harrier is the best-equipped, the XUV700 spells nice worth.
The refined Mahindra XUV700 is essentially the most highly effective of the lot and extra importantly, it’s moderately good to drive too. Massive on the surface, spacious and cozy on the within, and with its plush inside and prolonged gear record it makes you’re feeling such as you’ve spent your cash effectively. In abstract, Mahindra has hit the ball out of the park with the XUV700’s roundedness and intelligent packaging, and that’s why it wins this comparability take a look at fairly convincingly.
Additionally see:
Tata Harrier vs Jeep Compass vs Mahindra XUV700 comparability video
Tata Motors to launch three new SUVs in 2024
