Florida drivers, get ready for sharp increases in auto insurance rates

As home-owner insurance coverage premiums skyrocket, Florida drivers are getting an additional nasty shock this 12 months: Sharply elevated auto insurance coverage renewal charges.

Ana Curbelo says her month-to-month premium elevated from $170 to $280 to insure her 2004 Toyota Camry. “It’s loopy for this minimal protection,” she mentioned. “And I’m over 50.”

Jon Klapper says he simply obtained a renewal discover from Progressive that elevated his premium on his nine-year-old Kia Optima by 26%. “By no means had a declare,” he mentioned.

Robin Phillips says month-to-month insurance coverage premiums at the moment are greater than automobile funds. “The will increase needs to be for these which might be making claims and getting tickets and/or factors on their license,” she mentioned.

If it makes you are feeling any higher, auto insurance coverage fees are going up nationwide, consultants say, to meet up with post-pandemic inflation in restore and elements prices, will increase in crashes as we drive extra carelessly, and better automobile costs.

In fact, Florida being Florida, we get to pay extra-high will increase over and above the nationwide common as a result of numerous distinctive Florida components like hurricane harm, a excessive charge of uninsured drivers, excessive auto theft charges and claims fraud.

The South Florida Solar Sentinel reviewed main auto insurers’ charge filings with the Workplace of Insurance coverage Regulation and located that just about all the largest carriers imposed steep will increase a number of occasions that took impact during the last 12 months:

• United Companies Car Affiliation (USAA), insurer of greater than 1 million automobiles in Florida, elevated charges thrice since August 2022 for every of its 4 strains of insurance coverage. The entire elevated share charges vary from 33.9 for its Garrison Property & Casualty line to 57.3 for its largest USAA line.
• State Farm Mutual Car Insurance coverage Co., which insures 2.9 million Florida automobiles, took three charge will increase this 12 months totaling 30.2 share factors.
• Progressive took 4 will increase since July 2022 totaling greater than 30 share factors for every of its two main strains that cowl greater than 3.3 million automobiles within the state.
• Liberty Mutual’s three will increase since June 2022 drove common premiums up a complete 44.3 share factors for house owners of the 156,654 automobiles it insures.
• And Geico Basic Insurance coverage Co. hiked its charges twice since July 2022, totaling 23.8 share factors for its 2.5 million Florida automobiles.
• Auto Membership South, often known as AAA, just lately submitted a plan to extend charges for members of its “legacy” model by 39.7%, to be imposed over two years.

Requested by e mail to elucidate the sharp will increase, spokespersons for a number of of the businesses cited comparable causes, together with excessive inflation, materials shortages and excessive labor prices.

And Andrew Fernath, spokesman for USAA, identified that his firm solely sells to veterans and their households and presents “many private low cost alternatives that aren’t mirrored in state filings.”

It’s not simply Florida

Nationally, auto insurance coverage charges have elevated 17% since final summer time, says Mark Friedlander, of the industry-funded nonprofit Insurance coverage Info Institute.

An enormous motive is escalating accident “frequency,” the variety of crashes, and “severity,” what insurers should pay out, Friedlander mentioned.

Common price of car harm claims throughout the US elevated by practically 50% and common bodily harm claims rose 40% between 2018 and 2022, in line with a June report by the American Property and Casualty Insurance coverage Affiliation.

Will increase in distracted driving since People returned to the street following the pandemic triggered 420,000 extra crashes, 1,000 extra fatalities, and $10 billion in damages in 2022, the report mentioned, citing knowledge by Cambridge Cellular Telemetrics, which offers telemetrics purposes to insurers. Extra drivers are interacting with their gadgets, and extra typically, whereas on the street, contributing to a 23.4% improve in “display interplay time.”

Comply with traits affecting the native economic system

Subscribe to our free Enterprise by the Bay publication

We’ll break down the newest enterprise and client information and insights that you must know each Wednesday.

You’re all signed up!

Need extra of our free, weekly newsletters in your inbox? Let’s get began.

Discover all of your choices

Extra extreme accidents are resulting in a better quantity of claims that lead to lawsuits, which drives up prices, he mentioned.

The American Property and Casualty Insurance coverage Affiliation report cites a well-recognized grievance by insurers — rising prices of litigation.

“Throughout most strains, insurers are seeing an outsized progress in lawsuit verdicts, and in flip final claims settlement prices, ensuing from authorized system abuses which might be distorting what is taken into account applicable compensation and methods to get hold of it,” the report states.

Elevated verdicts are being seen for single-fatality crashes, crashes leading to private accidents, verdicts involving trucking or office class actions, and common verdicts, the report says.

The median verdict awarded in private harm crashes has elevated from $39,300 in 2010 to $125,366 in 2020, it mentioned.

As particular person verdicts attain new heights, they set up new precedent and affect future judgments — “fueling lawsuit inflation throughout all strains of enterprise,” the report mentioned.

Auto thefts are on the rise, spiking by 7% final 12 months and surpassing 1 million for the primary time since 2009, Friedlander mentioned. Sure Kia and Hyundai fashions that lack engine immobilizers are particularly simple to steal, he mentioned.

Lastly, excessive ranges of inflation because the pandemic have elevated costs of latest and used automobiles, substitute elements, and labor, Friedlander mentioned. Auto substitute prices rose 45.6% between 2019 and 2022, largely as a result of automobiles have gotten extra advanced and costly to restore, he mentioned.

Friedlander added that greater premiums imposed final 12 months weren’t masking “the escalating losses being paid out.” It’s why “we’ve got seen some auto insurers implement a number of charge will increase this 12 months,” he mentioned.

After the {industry} posted excessive underwriting losses in 2022, the institute is forecasting one other 12 months of losses in 2023, he mentioned. Which means insurers as a complete pays out extra in claims than they gather in premiums, requiring premium will increase for them to climb again into profitability.

However Florida is worse

Along with nationwide points, quite a few Florida-specific traits are sharpening the chunk for motorists within the Sunshine State, he mentioned.

They embrace the nation’s fourth-highest automobile theft charge. In 2022, Floridians misplaced 45,973 automobiles to thieves — a 6% improve over 2021.

Claims-fraud ranges are excessive within the state, notably staged accidents in South Florida and windshield substitute scams throughout the state.

The variety of lawsuits stemming from these glass substitute schemes in 2023 will probably surpass 2022′s report of 33,196, he mentioned. Lawsuits by drivers, regardless of latest authorized reforms banning one-way lawyer charges, are averaging greater than 50,000 a month within the state, Friedlander mentioned.

Florida additionally experiences excessive crash and fatality charges, and excessive charges of lethal “hit-and-run” crashes, he mentioned. In the meantime, 20.4% of Florida drivers are uninsured. After they crash, everybody else has to pay their payments.

Medical therapy prices for accident victims are rising in Florida, as are extreme climate occasions that trigger insurers to declare automobiles whole losses, he mentioned. Greater than 100,000 automobiles had been destroyed by Hurricane Ian final September, Friedlander mentioned.

Logan McFaddin, vp of state authorities relations for the American Property Casualty Insurance coverage Affiliation, mentioned reforms enacted within the final legislative session in March will “restabilize” Florida’s insurance coverage market, however it would take time for “the present wave of authorized system abuse to clean via the system.”

Listed below are your restricted choices to avoid wasting

In the meantime, drivers might marvel if there’s something they’ll do to scale back their auto insurance coverage prices.

The reply is just not actually — except you might be prepared to scale back your protection ranges or set up a tool that lets your insurer monitor your driving habits.

With all the main insurers rising premiums by comparable quantities, drivers can have a tough time searching for higher costs, acknowledges Divya Sangameshwar, spokeswoman for the consumer-focused insurance coverage price-comparison web site Worth Penguin.

The truth is, drivers who personal older automobiles, haven’t any tickets or accidents, personal their houses and have good credit score scores are probably already paying the bottom charges they’ll get with out decreasing protection ranges or rising deductibles, Sangameshwar says.

Whereas decreasing coverages or rising deductibles will help drivers who can’t pay greater charges, it’s a dangerous gambit that may improve probabilities you’ll be left unable to restore your automobile or be sued for uncovered bills by occupants of the automobile you hit.

Drivers with the very best probabilities of buying reductions are these with less-than-ideal credit score who’re insuring newer, costlier automobiles and already paying greater insurance coverage premiums, she mentioned.

She recommends visiting an unbiased insurance coverage agent with entry to protection from smaller, regional firms to seek out out if there are any obtainable lower-priced plans.

Friedlander supplied a listing of suggestions for tactics customers can scale back their auto insurance coverage prices:

• Get a number of quotes. “We suggest a minimal of three quotes to check prices — auto insurance coverage may be very aggressive and there could possibly be important worth variations between insurers,” he mentioned.
• Enroll in a telematics program, generally known as usage-based insurance coverage. Many firms now supply drivers the chance to put in a plug-in gadget or cellular app that may measure driving habits and worth protection accordingly. These gadgets monitor your common pace, how laborious and the way typically you brake, how shortly you speed up, and the time of day you drive. Secure drivers can save as much as a number of hundred {dollars}, he mentioned, however unsafe drivers may see their prices rise.
• Bundle residence and auto protection with the identical insurer. (That is harder in Florida, the place nationwide insurance coverage firms limit the forms of houses they’re prepared to insure.)
• Keep away from accidents or shifting violations for 3 years and earn safe-driver reductions.
• Pay your invoice in full at first of your time period.
• Enroll in paperless billing.
• Take a defensive driving course.
• Benefit from scholar and army reductions.