Mates, neighbors and state officers knew Sandy Sumner and Marie-Pierre Huguet for his or her gardens.
The couple housed an abundance of greens, which they tended rigorously and ate typically, in a whopping eight raised beds. Sandy had an inclination to get carried away, Huguet stated.
After the couple acquired a name from a state official in 2016 telling them to right away cease consuming their water — their nicely was contaminated with chemical compounds from a closed manufacturing facility close by — they knew they may not eat the greens fed with water from the faucet. They determined they didn’t need to watch the backyard die.
Huguet moved to Vermont from France greater than 30 years in the past, and she or he’s at all times been an awesome prepare dinner, in line with a detailed pal. William Sayer Sumner Jr., whom everybody referred to as “Sandy,” grew up in Pittsburgh and moved north after attending New England Faculty. His prolonged household lived in Vermont, and he visited routinely in the course of the summers.
Huguet recounted the stacks of frozen meals stockpiled in his fridge when she first met him, however quickly, he was a prepare dinner, too.
Sumner ripped up all eight raised beds whereas Huguet was away. It broke her coronary heart when she got here dwelling to the sight, she stated.
“You reside wholesome. You make selections,” she stated. “We didn’t have fancy automobiles or something like that. We had a stupendous, easy life that we constructed collectively.”
The backyard’s demise was solely the start of the affect chemical contamination had on their lives. Within the years to return, Sumner would search medical therapy after discovering a mass in his abdomen, which the physician would diagnose as undifferentiated pleomorphic sarcoma, a uncommon and aggressive most cancers.
The tumor measured 20 centimeters, Huguet stated. Throughout a December 2020 process, which Sumner practically didn’t survive, surgeons eliminated the tumor. By his checkup the next March, it had returned.
That’s once they knew Sumner’s sickness was terminal, Huguet stated. With the help of Vermont’s Act 39, a regulation that permits terminally ailing sufferers to finish their lives, Sumner died on Aug. 4, 2021, on the age of 69.
Sumner believed strongly that his publicity to PFOA induced his sickness, Huguet stated, although it’s practically unimaginable to make certain.
From the time he discovered of the contamination in his nicely, Sumner advocated for the residents inside the affected 26-square-mile space. With Huguet, he participated in a class-action lawsuit that resulted in a $34 million settlement final fall. When state officers wished to carry a gathering in Bennington to replace residents, they typically counted on Sumner to assist unfold the phrase. He invited lawmakers to his home, and he steadily spoke to members of the media.
Sumner supported a invoice that will give victims of poisonous chemical publicity an specific proper to sue accountable firms for medical monitoring prices. Two earlier iterations of the invoice had been vetoed by Gov. Phil Scott, and a brand new invoice, S.113, is now taking a flip via the state Legislature.
Huguet needs to see it move.
In early February, with a VTDigger reporter and photographer, Huguet sat on the kitchen desk in a brand new residence within the heart of downtown Bennington. Sumner made the preparations for her earlier than he died. From her home windows, she will see downtown and the closest mountains.
All through the final a number of years, Huguet has been current for each assembly and concerned in each dialog about PFOA contamination, she stated, however Sumner was at all times the spokesperson.
“Folks don’t actually know me — I used to be behind him,” Huguet stated. “I used to be joyful behind him. I used to be at all times quiet and listening. So now I’ve to talk up as a result of it mattered to him.”
A regarding name
Richard Spiese, a hazardous web site supervisor with Vermont’s Division of Environmental Conservation, met Sumner for the primary time when he took a pattern from Sumner’s nicely in 2016.
In February of that 12 months, on the heels of the invention of widespread PFOA contamination in Hoosick Falls, New York, Spiese had been requested to pattern some non-public wells in Bennington primarily based on a priority in regards to the ChemFab plant, which closed in 2002. It’s at present owned by Saint Gobain, a global plastics firm.
Spiese was thought of an skilled on the time, he stated with fun, due to a webinar he had seen.
“That tells you ways a lot we knew about PFAS at that time,” he stated.
PFAS, or perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances, is a category of human-made chemical compounds which have lengthy been hailed in sure industries due to their outstanding capacity to make merchandise nonstick and waterproof. Usually referred to as a “eternally chemical,” they take a really very long time to interrupt down.
The chemical nonetheless isn’t regulated on the federal degree, however over time, the Environmental Safety Company has linked PFAS to unfavourable human well being impacts equivalent to decreased fertility and hypertension in pregnant folks, developmental delays, sure cancers, suppressed immune techniques and excessive ldl cholesterol.
Within the early ’90s, Sumner and Huguet observed black mud coming from the ChemFab manufacturing facility down the hill from their dwelling. Each of them began having frequent nosebleeds. Sumner contacted the manufacturing facility on the time to complain.
Huguet stated she knew in regards to the contamination in Hoosick Falls, however it by no means occurred to her that the identical factor could possibly be occurring in Bennington.
“Once we met Richard, I bear in mind trying again on the irony of it — joking, laughing,” she stated. “‘Yeah, do no matter you need, take a look at the water, it’s good.’ We didn’t know.”
Spiese’s pattern of the Sumners’ nicely got here again with alarmingly excessive ranges of PFOA. As Huguet tells it, a frantic state official phoned the couple to inform them to right away cease consuming their water and to “strive to not breathe when having a shower.” The primary studying confirmed 580 elements per trillion, and a second take a look at confirmed 780 elements per trillion, whereas the state’s restrict for consuming water is 20 elements per trillion.
The couple had been consuming the water for many years. Later, exams confirmed extraordinarily excessive ranges of their blood: 305 micrograms per liter in Sumner’s and 415 micrograms per liter in Huguet’s, tons of of occasions greater than the two.1 micrograms discovered on common throughout the nation, and nonetheless considerably greater than the ten micrograms on common in affected folks in Bennington.
Throughout the years ChemFab’s plant was working, it emitted hundreds of kilos of PFOA via its smokestacks. Contamination reached a 26-square-mile space — 18 occasions the dimensions of Central Park — impacting round 2,700 residential properties and eight,000 residents in Bennington, North Bennington and Shaftsbury.
The state sued Saint Gobain and reached a settlement in 2019. It targeted totally on making certain residents had entry to wash consuming water and helped the municipalities prolong water strains to neighborhoods so residents might shift away from nicely water.
Individually, some residents, together with Huguet and Sumner, filed a category motion lawsuit in opposition to Saint Gobain for property injury and bills to watch their well being. The $34 million settlement, reached final fall, was the results of 5 years of litigation.
“Sandy and I didn’t imagine in anger,” Huguet stated. “That’s not an emotion we cared about. If we will chortle at one thing, we’re good to go. However Sandy was indignant. He tried to not let it affect him an excessive amount of as a result of it was, once more, an alien emotion. However he was going to do all the pieces in his energy to make it possible for Saint Gobain took accountability.”
Reason for motion
Sumner died earlier than he may gain advantage from the $34 million settlement. It might have given him entry to medical monitoring, which might have helped him catch his sickness sooner or plan for it.
Nevertheless, a statewide coverage that will assist sufferers entry medical monitoring prices could have helped him, Huguet stated. Proposals for such a coverage have cleared the state’s Legislature twice however had been vetoed each occasions by Gov. Phil Scott, who cited potential impacts on companies.
The invoice would give victims of poisonous chemical publicity — those that do and don’t present signs — a explanation for motion to allow them to sue the businesses liable for the air pollution. The coverage wouldn’t cowl the price of medical therapy. It’s too troublesome to show that anyone specific sickness got here from PFOA. Nonetheless, Sumner was an ardent advocate.
“When you’ve been impacted by one thing, your medical monitoring course of must be paid by these folks which might be liable for that form of air pollution,” stated Sen. Brian Campion, D-Bennington, who co-sponsored the invoice with Sen. Dick Sears, D-Bennington.
The brand new model of the invoice just lately cleared the Senate, and Scott has given some indications that he may signal it.
“I don’t know all the small print of it, however it appears to be like significantly better than the payments beforehand on my desk,” he stated throughout a press briefing in early February.
Companies and insurance coverage firms stay cautious. The regulation could be the primary of its variety within the nation, and insurers haven’t but carved out protection insurance policies to handle the potential new type of legal responsibility.
Jamie Feehan, a lobbyist with the American Property and Casualty Insurance coverage Affiliation, instructed lawmakers that the brand new explanation for motion for medical monitoring “poses a brand new danger, or a broadening of an present danger, that insurers will now have to think about in writing a coverage.”
Lack of present precedent complicates issues extra, he stated.
“Does an insurer really feel snug persevering with to offer insurance coverage to an organization impacted by this invoice?” he stated. “Will the insurer write a brand new coverage on this space for a corporation? This may go away the insured to search for different industrial insurers or to the excess strains market to fill this legal responsibility want.”
Advocates of the laws say these uncovered to contaminants mustn’t entrance the price of monitoring their well being. Underneath the class-action settlement, Bennington residents have entry to these bills, however the five-year, multimillion-dollar course of proved how troublesome it could be for different victims of chemical publicity to assert the identical companies.
Emily Joselson, an legal professional with the Middlebury agency Langrock, Sperry and Wool, who represented Bennington residents within the class-action swimsuit, stated throughout testimony earlier than lawmakers earlier this month that she isn’t certain her agency will tackle one other case of this magnitude.
“I do know few different Vermont companies able to or keen to danger a five-plus-year litigation of this type in opposition to an enormous and well-financed company,” Joselson stated. “The prices and the dangers are just too nice. That’s why we want S.113.”
Jim Sullivan, who labored to arrange neighbors within the class-action settlement, instructed lawmakers he can “definitely perceive issues from business perspective, and prices and dangers.
“However our prices and dangers are very quick and really private and really profound,” he stated.
It’s onerous to find out what, precisely, Sumner would have gained from medical monitoring, Huguet stated. It wouldn’t have saved him, she is aware of. Perhaps it could have offered peace of thoughts, extra time to plan, extra consciousness of their scenario, the power to deal with the most cancers otherwise, a chance to go see Huguet’s household in France to whom Sumner by no means stated goodbye.
“To me, it’s such a fundamental proper,” she stated.
In a 2019 interview with VTDigger, Sumner instructed reporters he spent cash out of pocket for his medical monitoring bills. Different neighbors who had been additionally uncovered have had “relatable” cancers, Sumner stated, which means they’re related to publicity to PFAS.
“I need to dwell so long as I can,” he stated on the time. “I need the choice of residing out a pure life with out this interference, interruption. And we simply don’t know. We really feel like that freedom has form of been taken away from us.”
What’s already misplaced
Close to the top of Sumner’s life, Huguet started to hate Wednesdays. Sumner wished to ensure all the pieces was so as when he died, and Huguet didn’t have work conferences these days, in order that they started to fill with legal professionals and docs appointments.
However humor wasn’t misplaced. Huguet and Sumner bantered about urns on the funeral dwelling. Sumner insisted on making his personal preparations so Huguet wouldn’t need to.
Sumner took out an advert within the Bennington Banner and wrote his personal obituary — a number of brief strains delivering information about his loss of life and details about the place to donate. Instead of a funeral, he wished a celebration of life.
His loss of life has develop into a name to motion for advocates of medical monitoring and a logo of the continuing affect of the contamination in Bennington.
Spiese, the state official who first monitored Sumners’ nicely, developed a friendship with Sumner through the years he traveled to Bennington. He remembers sitting on his porch, speaking about PFOA and different issues — the city, the backyard, politics.
“When his obituary got here out, somebody despatched it to me. I imply, I used to be — it’s simply such a loss for the world,” Spiese stated. “He believed adamantly that we wanted to do what we might do to make the world a greater place. I don’t need to say it’s a uncommon particular person, there’s in all probability greater than I do know, however he was definitely the poster baby for that perspective.”
When John Camelio moved to Bennington, Sumner was one of many first folks he met. They turned quick buddies, seeing one another daily, shoveling snow for neighbors and {golfing} collectively. Sumner was a carpenter and Camelio restored furnishings. When two extra of their neighbors had been identified with most cancers, they talked via it collectively. When Sumner died, Camelio spoke at his memorial.
Now, he typically appears to be like throughout the road, and whereas he’s joyful to see a brand new, younger couple residing within the dwelling, he misses his pal.
“If I noticed Sandy out within the yard, I’d go on the market, and we’d have our talks,” Camelio stated. “He’d name me, ‘we’re going for a stroll.’ He’d name me, ‘we’re going to play golf.’ , ‘let’s eat over.’ Let’s do that. Let’s try this. It’s left its mark. Everybody beloved Sandy.”
Huguet is making good on her plans to talk out. She testified earlier than lawmakers within the Senate Judiciary Committee earlier this session, a course of she stated broke her coronary heart in the course of the course of and after — having to sum up the life she shared together with her husband in paragraphs on paper.
“By no fault of our personal, I misplaced my husband. I misplaced my high quality of life. I needed to promote my dwelling, and I’ll fear about my well being for the remainder of my life,” she instructed the committee. “All I did was drink water.
“I don’t want any Vermonter, or anybody for that matter, to undergo what I went via.”
Do not miss a factor. Enroll right here to get VTDigger’s weekly e mail on the vitality business and the setting.
