Toyota And Subaru Face Class Action Lawsuit Over GT86 and BRZ Engine Failures

Points with the Subaru-designed four-cylinder boxer engines used within the Toyota GR 86, the Subaru BRZ, and the now defunct Scion FR-S, have been reported on for a number of years now. It appeared inevitable after so many reviews and viral cases of the engines failing, that there could be a category motion lawsuit. Now, it is right here, in keeping with a report by CarComplaints.com. The lawsuit was filed within the U.S. District Court docket for the District of New Jersey by plaintiff Laura Younger, who purchased a used 2019 Toyota GR86 in 2021, however the concern issues each the two.0-liter engine from the previous-generation sports activities automobile and the brand new 2.4-liter engine within the present fashions.

2024 Toyota GR86
Base MSRP
$29,300
Engine
2.4-Liter 4-Cylinder
Horsepower
228 hp
Gas Financial system
20/26/22 mpg (Handbook) | 21/30/24 mpg (Computerized)
2024 Subaru BRZ
Base MSRP
$30,195
Engine
2.4L Flat 4 Gasoline
Horsepower
228 hp
Gas Financial system
20/27 MPG

Claims Of The Lawsuit

In keeping with the lawsuit, the engine failed with 64,000 miles on the odometer – 4,000 miles past the producer’s five-year/60,000-mile guarantee, leaving Younger out of pocket for a substitute. In April of 2023, Younger had her automobile towed to an auto restore store (not specified as a Toyota dealership) after the engine misplaced energy, leaving her stranded.

“Upon an entire skilled teardown of the engine, it was decided that the engine failure was on account of oil hunger, lack of the oil movie and extreme put on. At current, Ms. Younger’s automobile remains to be disabled and Defendants haven’t changed her faulty engine with a non-defective one.”
– Excerpt f
rom the Toyota Subaru boxer engine lawsuit.

Add CarBuzz to your Google Information feed.

Oil hunger as the reason for the boxer engine’s failures is typical of the numerous reviews throughout the web. The overall consensus is that sealant from the oil pan gasket will get into the oil and blocks a tube, ravenous the remainder of the engine of oil. The difficulty seems to originate from the flawed sealant being utilized too liberally on the manufacturing facility, then the surplus sealant will get heated up throughout use, softening it up and permitting it to be dislodged instantly into the oil pan. The lawsuit alleges Toyota and Subaru used room temperature vulcanizing (RTV) silicone rather than conventional gaskets, and claims Toyota and Subaru knew of the difficulty and that the engines had been faulty, however selected to “conceal it from purchasers.”

An Ongoing Problem

Sometimes, the reviews come from engines failing throughout or after monitor classes, when the engine is most below stress, not throughout common highway driving. We do not know the historical past of the automobile earlier than Younger purchased it, or if she had taken it to a monitor. Nevertheless it should not matter if any manufacturing facility sports activities automobile is taken to the monitor (assuming it is properly maintained and nonetheless inventory) – it is actually part of how Toyota and Subaru marketed the automobile.

Associated

Your Full Information To The Boxer Engine

Is the ‘flat engine’ too good, or simply too good to be true?

Early on and because the concern surfaced, Toyota pushed again on honoring a guaranty on an 86 because it had been entered in a high-performance driving occasion. Predictably, the story went viral and drew an enormous quantity of criticism. Toyota correctly relented and began honoring warranties, however with this lawsuit, the story is much from over.